The relationship dynamics in the reality series The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives took a surprising turn during the season three finale, aired on November 13, 2024. Taylor Frankie Paul, known for her tumultuous romantic history, hinted at a potential rekindling of her relationship with Chase McWhorter, after an earlier scandal that involved both of them.
During a lunch meeting captured on the show, Chase apologized to Taylor for his past behavior, reflecting on their shared experiences. Their conversation included lighthearted moments, such as joking about sharing a kiss, contrasting sharply with their earlier interactions marked by controversy. Just before the show’s premiere in September 2024, Taylor had made headlines due to her involvement in a “soft swinging” scandal while still married to Tate Paul. This controversy featured her encounters with multiple couples, including Chase and his then-wife, Miranda McWhorter.
Taylor revealed the complexities surrounding her relationship with Chase, stating, “Her husband was the one who had feelings for me. That’s where the story gets confusing.” This comment highlighted the tensions that arose after she admitted to having a dream about Chase, which escalated tensions among her social circle. Following the fallout, Taylor and Tate, who share two children, ended their marriage.
Chase, who divorced Miranda in 2024, noted in an interview with Us Weekly that the circumstances surrounding their relationships led to regrets. He expressed concern about how their private lives became public, stating, “I think we all have regrets… It seems like this was all happening behind closed doors, and now Taylor’s using it as a springboard to notoriety.”
Chase McWhorter’s Relationship Timeline
Chase and Miranda began dating in 2016 after he contacted her via social media and married a year later. The couple welcomed two children, Brooks in 2019 and Cohen in 2021, before ultimately separating in 2024. Chase characterized their breakup as a realization of having married too young. He mentioned their amicable relationship post-divorce, stating, “We’re really cordial, really friendly.”
After his marriage ended, Chase was linked with Layla Taylor before beginning a relationship with Kate Racker. His involvement in the soft-swinging scandal reportedly originated during the COVID-19 pandemic, involving parties with friends that led to unexpected romantic encounters. Chase clarified, “It was never predetermined that we were going to be doing, like, swinging. That’s what we always thought was a little bit misrepresented in Taylor’s story.”
The Current Status of Chase and Taylor
In the season finale, Chase revealed he had recently ended his relationship with Kate, leading to speculation about his intentions with Taylor. Their lunch conversation took on a more intimate tone as he referred to their meeting as a date. Chase shared his admiration for Taylor, stating, “Honestly, Taylor, I always thought you were one of the coolest people ever.”
Taylor acknowledged her flirty nature, adding that her interactions with Chase felt natural. The episode concluded with Chase proposing a kiss “for old times’ sake,” leaving viewers questioning the future of their connection.
Since filming, Taylor has been cast as the lead in a new season of The Bachelorette, suggesting that any rekindled romance with Chase may not be in the cards.
Chase’s presence continues to generate controversy, particularly with his podcast OnlyDads, which has drawn criticism from fellow cast members. Mayci Neeley publicly called out Chase for derogatory comments, underscoring ongoing tensions within the MomTok community.
As the dynamics of their relationships unfold, both Chase and Taylor remain figures of interest in the evolving narrative of reality television, capturing the complexities of love, friendship, and public scrutiny.
