UPDATE: In a heart-stopping PSAL 4A city championship game on December 3, 2023, Tottenville’s hopes for a city title were dashed as they fell to Erasmus Hall, 34-27, at Midwood High School in Brooklyn, NY. The Pirates, led by star running back Tyshawn Bent, who electrified the crowd with a touchdown on the opening kickoff, fought valiantly but ultimately could not secure their first city title in 22 years.
The game started with promise for Tottenville as Bent’s explosive return set the tone. However, Erasmus Hall, a dominant force in high school football, quickly regrouped. The Dutchmen, featuring a formidable trio of quarterback Kendu Brown, running back Ameir Morrow, and wide receiver Justus Murray, responded with a relentless offensive display that secured their victory.
This thrilling matchup marked the end of an impressive season for Tottenville, finishing with a record of 12-1. Head coach Brian Neville expressed pride in his team’s performance, despite the heartbreaking loss. “We fought hard all season, and I couldn’t be prouder of these boys,” Neville stated.
Erasmus Hall, now with a 10-2 record, not only avenged their previous loss to Tottenville earlier in the season but also celebrated their seventh city championship title. This victory propels them ahead of Susan Wagner’s six titles and places them just one behind Curtis, who holds the record for eight championships in league play.
Fans were on the edge of their seats as the game unfolded, with both teams showcasing incredible athleticism and determination. The emotional stakes were high, as Tottenville’s seniors looked to end their high school careers with a championship win.
As celebrations erupted on the Erasmus side, Tottenville is left to reflect on a season filled with challenges and triumphs. The Pirates will regroup and look ahead, with the promise of future seasons and the hope of finally breaking their championship drought.
Stay tuned for more updates as we continue to cover the aftermath of this thrilling championship showdown.
