UPDATE: Nimmo United Methodist Church, the oldest continuously operating Methodist church in the United States, is urgently seeking to be removed from the historic zoning designation that governs its renovations and repairs. This request was formally presented to the Virginia Beach Planning Commission on December 6, 2023, raising significant concerns about the financial implications of strict preservation standards.
The church’s representatives were absent during the critical meeting, prompting questions from the Planning Commission regarding the reasons behind the appeal. City officials are expressing unease over whether the current review board’s regulations are excessively stringent and financially burdensome for property owners.
According to Mark Reed, Virginia Beach’s historic preservation planner, the church’s appeal stems from “significant material and labor costs associated with repairs and improvements desired by the church.” The Planning Commission has deferred the decision on this matter until January 14, 2024, as they await further information from church officials.
Commissioner Bryan Plumlee highlighted the importance of this issue, indicating that it may have broader implications for historic districts citywide. “It’s an important issue affecting our consideration of this district and other districts throughout the city,” he stated.
Nimmo United Methodist Church is located near the intersection of General Booth Boulevard and Princess Anne Road, within the Nimmo Church Historical and Cultural District established in 1980. This district is one of 16 Historical and Cultural Districts in Virginia Beach designed to protect structures from various eras, including the Colonial period.
Currently, the city’s Historic Review Board and the Historic Preservation Commission have both denied the church’s request to be removed from the district. They argue that approval would create a dangerous precedent and remove essential protections for the church, which is integral to Virginia Beach’s historical identity.
Councilwoman Barbara Henley, who represents the district housing the church, acknowledged her awareness of the request and expressed concerns regarding the high standards imposed by the review board. “Being in the (historic and cultural) district, they’re just required to meet the highest standard of historic preservation,” she noted. Henley is hopeful that a compromise can be reached that accommodates both the city’s preservation goals and the church’s need for financial feasibility.
The church has not recently submitted any applications for maintenance or repair, leaving the exact nature of the repairs and improvements unclear. In 2021, the Historic Review Board approved three additions to the church but rejected a proposal for a welcome center due to its proximity to the historic steeple, which was added in 1893.
As the situation unfolds, the implications for Virginia Beach’s approach to historic preservation remain significant. Stakeholders are watching closely to see if the church will present further details or alternative solutions before the next Planning Commission meeting.
This developing story highlights the ongoing tension between preserving historical integrity and addressing the practical needs of property owners in designated districts. As the January meeting approaches, both local officials and church members are under pressure to find a resolution that balances these competing interests.
Stay tuned for updates as this critical issue evolves.
