The Miami Dolphins are grappling with significant challenges in their defensive line, particularly concerning the performance of rookie edge rusher Chop Robinson. Drafted 21st overall in the 2024 NFL Draft, Robinson’s early career statistics have raised alarms among fans and analysts alike, leading to questions about the team’s overall strategy and roster decisions.
After a promising start to the 2023 season, the Dolphins finished with an 11-6 record, but their postseason ambitions were thwarted by a Wildcard playoff loss against the Kansas City Chiefs. The team’s defensive struggles were glaring, particularly in the absence of key players such as Jaelan Phillips and Bradley Chubb, who were sidelined due to serious injuries. Phillips suffered a torn Achilles, while Chubb sustained multiple ligament tears during the final regular-season game. This left Miami’s pass rush severely depleted.
Draft Decisions and Expectations
Despite their investment in Phillips and Chubb, the Dolphins decided to target another edge rusher in the draft, reflecting the dire need for depth and performance in that position. According to sources, Miami’s management had a keen interest in Robinson after scouting him extensively during his time at Penn State. In meetings with the coaching staff, including head coach Mike McDaniel, the team expressed confidence in his potential.
Robinson’s nickname, “Chop,” originated from family anecdotes about his birth weight of 14 pounds. While his athleticism and explosiveness garnered attention—he was listed as ninth on Bruce Feldman’s Freaks List—his college performance raised concerns. In three seasons at Penn State, he recorded only 11.5 sacks, which many analysts viewed as a red flag regarding his ability to transition to the NFL.
In his rookie season, Robinson began slowly, recording just six sacks but showing signs of growth. However, as the 2025 season progresses, he has struggled to maintain that trajectory. With just 10 tackles and four sacks to date, his production has not met the expectations set by his draft position.
Comparative Analysis of Performance
The statistics tell a stark story. Robinson’s pressure rate is alarmingly low compared to his peers. As of now, he has recorded only 19 pressures, 5 hits, and 15 hurries, marking a pass rush win rate of just 8.8%. This places him 125th among all edge rushers, a concerning statistic for a player taken in the first round.
When compared to other edge rushers from his draft class, such as Jared Verse and Laiatu Latu, who have 72 and 51 pressures, respectively, Robinson’s numbers highlight a troubling trend. His limited impact has raised questions about his ability to develop into a reliable starter, particularly given Miami’s need for robust defensive play.
Concerns extend beyond mere statistics. Robinson has often been asked to drop into coverage, reflecting a lack of trust from defensive coordinator Anthony Weaver. While Weaver has successfully coached similar players in previous roles, the current trajectory of Robinson’s career suggests that he may not fully realize his potential.
As the Dolphins look toward the future, they face a critical juncture. The franchise has a history of high-profile draft disappointments, and the need to reinforce the edge rusher position is pressing. Although it may be premature to label Robinson a bust, the pressure is mounting for him to demonstrate significant improvement.
With their last playoff victory dating back to December 30, 2000, against the Indianapolis Colts, the Dolphins are eager to break the cycle of disappointment. If they are to return to playoff contention, Robinson’s performance must elevate considerably. The franchise’s hopes for a competitive edge rely heavily on his ability to adapt and excel in the challenging landscape of the NFL.
As Miami prepares for their final game of the season, Robinson’s status remains uncertain due to a concussion sustained in a recent match against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. Regardless of his availability, the need for a comprehensive evaluation of the edge rusher position is clear. The Dolphins cannot afford to miss another opportunity to solidify their roster and achieve the long-awaited success their fans crave.
