Hulu has officially renewed the legal drama series All’s Fair, headlined by Kim Kardashian, for a second season. This decision comes just three weeks after the show’s debut on November 4, 2023. Despite receiving a wave of negative critical reviews, the series managed to draw a substantial viewership, marking a significant achievement for the streaming platform.
The show, co-created and executive produced by Ryan Murphy, attracted approximately 3.2 million views in its first three days, calculated by total viewing minutes divided by running time. This figure signifies the best start for any original scripted series on Hulu in three years, showcasing the audience’s interest despite the critical backlash. Official U.S. streaming ratings from Nielsen will be available in early December, providing further context to the show’s performance.
Mixed Reception from Audiences and Critics
While critics have not favored All’s Fair, with some branding it as one of the worst shows of the year, audience feedback offers a slightly brighter picture. The series holds a 66 percent approval rating from viewers on Rotten Tomatoes. However, it has fared worse on Metacritic, where it received a user score of 2.5 out of 10, which is somewhat more favorable than its critics’ score of 17 out of 100.
The drama stars Kardashian as Allura Grant, a high-powered divorce lawyer in Los Angeles known for securing significant settlements for female clients. The ensemble cast includes notable names such as Naomi Watts, Niecy Nash-Betts, Teyana Taylor, Matthew Noszka, Sarah Paulson, and Glenn Close.
A Strong Creative Team Behind the Scenes
The series is produced by 20th Television, where Murphy is based. Alongside Murphy, the creative team includes Jon Robin Baitz and Joe Baken, who co-created the show, as well as writers and executive producers Jamie Pachino, Lyn Greene, and Richard Levine. Additional executive producers include Kardashian, Close, Watts, Nash-Betts, and Paulson, along with Anthony Hemingway, Kris Jenner, Eric Kovtun, Scott Robertson, and Nissa Diederich. Both Murphy and Hemingway also contribute as directors.
The success of All’s Fair despite its polarizing reception highlights the complexities of audience engagement in today’s entertainment landscape. Hulu’s decision to renew the series indicates its confidence in the show’s potential for future seasons, suggesting a willingness to invest in content that resonates with viewers, even in the face of critical scrutiny.
