The Ulster County Legislature’s Housing and Transportation Committee has postponed a decision regarding a proposal to assess surplus county properties for their potential use in developing tiny homes aimed at supporting homeless veterans and other vulnerable populations. The proposal, put forth by Legislator Herbert Litts, seeks to alleviate the county’s reliance on temporary motel accommodations, which cost approximately $13.3 million annually.
Proposal Details and Legislative Reactions
During the committee meeting on October 9, 2023, Litts expressed his concerns about the negative impact of temporary housing on individuals’ self-esteem. He stated, “Several years ago, it became apparent to me that living out of a suitcase in not very nice accommodations and moving every 30 days was not a way to live.” Litts emphasized the importance of providing stable, permanent housing to prevent individuals from being shuffled among various counties.
Among the properties Litts identified for potential development is Paradise Lane in New Paltz, where the county is currently constructing an emergency communications center. He argued that the site could be suitable for tiny homes since utilities are already being installed under the Thruway for the new center.
While the committee members acknowledged the need for affordable housing, Democratic legislators expressed skepticism regarding Litts’ plan. Committee Chairman Jeff Collins questioned how the proposed tiny home initiative would differ from existing county efforts. Other members raised concerns that a narrow focus on tiny homes might inhibit alternative development strategies.
Calls for a Holistic Approach
Legislature Chairman Peter Criswell commented that the proposal seemed to lack comprehensive input from administration officials and department heads, suggesting a need for a more coordinated approach. “I just think we have to have a holistic approach,” said Criswell, a member of the Democratic Party.
In response to concerns about collaboration, Litts stated that he had previously discussed the proposal with County Executive Jen Metzger and her administration. He characterized the policy as an additional tool for the county’s housing strategy, aiming to ensure every property is evaluated for its potential to support tiny home developments.
Ultimately, the committee decided to delay the vote on the proposal. Democrats Eric Stewart, Debra Clinton, and Greg McCollough expressed their willingness to work alongside Litts to refine the policy before it is presented to the full Legislature.
The future of tiny home developments in Ulster County remains uncertain as the committee continues to weigh the viability of the proposal against the backdrop of existing housing strategies and community needs.
